I've been excited since the time I started playing for getting a gembound for my birthday ; x ;
I mean its my fault for joining the site last minute, and having a birthday in February, but I think its kind of lame to not tell people that you're going to change it each year because it gets peoples hopes up.

Regardless, I voted for minipet ^^

Not a new minipet, but a new birthday color of an existing pet.

there should be an option to keep the plushies, they're nonmagical so it's not like everybody is getting a free gembound.

Wait... Were the birthday gift gembound plushes non-magical? (I never got one, so I know nothing. :P)

agreeing with MariahKat, mini pets and plushes sound like a horrible idea, maybe if there was a massive userbase on here most of which don't care about collecting at all which would make it less ridiculous for collectors to go for, but that's clearly not the case. either it has to be just a single type of mini pet/plush throughout the year or it's honestly better to not release either one of those at all.

CherieBits But plushies and minipets are part of a collection feature, A minipet might breed if lucky (but boy would they be inflated for a long while) but you cant exactly breed a month exclusive plush...Thus why I'm saying at least those two items need to be the same for everyone.

I mean, i think the whole point is that they ARE limited?? MariahKat

erm but wouldn't those all be month exclusive thus expensive and limited?...Unless it's the same item no mater which month to avoid them being too limited.

Maybe if you already have the non-magic gembound plush, why not just a magical version of it?

Maybe a mini pet that represents your birthstone???